Sicily Osteria

Sicily Osteria

328-330 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

(646) 609-3417
4.6 (3,456 reviews)
Open Now
Advertisement

Opening Hours

Tuesday
12–10 PM
Wednesday
12–11 PM
Thursday Today Open Now
12–11 PM
Friday
12–11 PM
Saturday
12–11 PM
Sunday
12–10 PM
Monday
12–10 PM

Customer Reviews & Ratings

4.6
Based on 3,456 customer ratings & reviews
5 Stars
68%
4 Stars
22%
3 Stars
6%
2 Stars
2%
1 Star
2%

Other Restaurants in New York

Sugar Factory New York - Time Square 0.1 mi away

Sugar Factory New York - Time Square

694 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States

4.6 (7,610 reviews)
View Menu
Glass House Tavern 0.1 mi away

Glass House Tavern

252 W 47th St #14, New York, NY 10036

4.5 (1,805 reviews)
View Menu
Times Square Diner & Grill 0.2 mi away

Times Square Diner & Grill

807 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019

4.4 (5,010 reviews)
View Menu
Bea 0.2 mi away

Bea

403 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

4.4 (2,092 reviews)
View Menu
Da Marino NYC 0.2 mi away

Da Marino NYC

220 W 49th St Apt 222, New York, NY 10019

4.2 (1,072 reviews)
View Menu
Carnegie Diner & Cafe 0.2 mi away

Carnegie Diner & Cafe

828 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019

4.5 (3,815 reviews)
View Menu

Weekly Hours

  • Tuesday 12–10 PM
  • Wednesday 12–11 PM
  • Thursday Today Open Now 12–11 PM
  • Friday 12–11 PM
  • Saturday 12–11 PM
  • Sunday 12–10 PM
  • Monday 12–10 PM

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Sicily Osteria accommodate guests catching a Broadway show?

Located right in the Theater District near Times Square, Sicily Osteria is well-equipped for pre-theater pacing. Informing your server of your show curtain time allows the kitchen to structure your meal efficiently, serving appetizers and hand-cut pasta dishes within an ideal timeframe.

Are there dietary options for gluten-free or vegetarian diners?

Yes, vegetarian options include dishes like Paccheri alla Norma ($26), Ricotta al Forno ($16), and baked Eggplant Parmigiana ($28). Gluten-free diners can choose from naturally wheat-free items such as the charred Polipo alla Piastra ($25), grilled Branzino ($37), and roasted Lemon Potatoes ($10).

What traditional Sicilian street foods are featured on the menu?

The 'La Strada' menu highlights traditional Sicilian street food classics, including Panelle ($12, chickpea fritters seasoned with fresh lemon zest), Crocchè ($13, potato croquettes stuffed with smoked provola and pistachio pesto), and Arancini ($15, saffron rice balls filled with molten mozzarella and spicy 'nduja).

Does Sicily Osteria offer a bottomless brunch option?

Sicily Osteria offers a weekend brunch featuring a $20 add-on for two hours of bottomless beverages, including Mimosa, Bellini, Bloody Mary, Screwdriver, or Sangria. Brunch entrees range from savory Purgatorio Siciliano (baked eggs with spicy tomato sauce) to decadent Pistachio French Toast.

What is the signature dessert at Sicily Osteria?

The restaurant's signature dessert is the Limone di Sicilia ($17), an artisanal sculpted lemon-shaped cheesecake mousse filled with lemon confit, mint, and a salty crumble. Other standout house desserts include Sicilian pistachio Basque cheesecake, housemade tiramisu, and crispy double cannoli.

Advertisement

Non-Affiliation & Fair Use Disclaimer

MenuRates is an independent restaurant menu archive and price directory. We are not officially affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to Sicily Osteria or any of its subsidiaries. All registered trademarks, logos, brand names, and menu item names remain the sole property of their respective owners and are displayed here under Fair Use guidelines for informational purposes only. For menu corrections or takedown requests, please visit our Disclaimer or Contact Page.