Carnegie Diner & Cafe

Carnegie Diner & Cafe

828 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019

(212) 399-4444
4.5 (3,815 reviews)
Open Now
Advertisement

Opening Hours

Friday
7 AM–1 AM
Saturday
7 AM–1 AM
Sunday
7 AM–1 AM
Monday
7 AM–1 AM
Tuesday
7 AM–1 AM
Wednesday
7 AM–1 AM
Thursday Today Open Now
7 AM–1 AM

Customer Reviews & Ratings

4.5
Based on 3,815 customer ratings & reviews
5 Stars
68%
4 Stars
22%
3 Stars
6%
2 Stars
2%
1 Star
2%

Other Restaurants in New York

Times Square Diner & Grill 0.1 mi away

Times Square Diner & Grill

807 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019

4.4 (5,010 reviews)
View Menu
Da Marino NYC 0.1 mi away

Da Marino NYC

220 W 49th St Apt 222, New York, NY 10019

4.2 (1,072 reviews)
View Menu
Victor's Cafe Cuban Restaurant 0.1 mi away

Victor's Cafe Cuban Restaurant

236 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019

4.4 (2,594 reviews)
View Menu
Ellen's Stardust Diner 0.1 mi away

Ellen's Stardust Diner

1650 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States

4.4 (24,591 reviews)
View Menu
Glass House Tavern 0.1 mi away

Glass House Tavern

252 W 47th St #14, New York, NY 10036

4.5 (1,805 reviews)
View Menu
Briciola 0.2 mi away

Briciola

370 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019

4.5 (1,564 reviews)
View Menu

Weekly Hours

  • Friday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Saturday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Sunday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Monday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Tuesday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Wednesday 7 AM–1 AM
  • Thursday Today Open Now 7 AM–1 AM

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes the pastrami sandwiches at Carnegie Diner & Cafe unique?

Carnegie Diner elevates traditional New York deli pastrami by using premium Naval Wagyu pastrami served warm on seedless rye. Options range from half-pound classic sandwiches to the massive 18-ounce WOW Pastrami Sandwich and the Egg-Strami topped with sunny-side-up organic eggs and melted Swiss cheese.

Are there vegetarian and vegan options available on the menu?

Yes, the restaurant features an extensive plant-based menu section. Highlights include the Impossible Vegan Burger served on a gluten-free bun, Vegan Yeero and Souvlaki on sprouted grain wheatberry bread, Vegan Meatball Subs with plant-based mozzarella, and plant-based egg breakfast sandwiches.

What kind of specialty milkshakes and desserts are offered?

Carnegie Diner is famous for its over-the-top specialty milkshakes served with entire desserts atop the glass, such as the Chocolate Pancake Strawberry Milkshake, Waffle Ice Cream Sandwich Milkshake, and Brownie Extravaganza. Dessert highlights also include their towering 24-Layer Chocolate Cake and traditional New York Style Cheesecake.

Is Carnegie Diner & Cafe a good spot for dining after a Broadway show?

Yes, located at 828 8th Ave near major Broadway theater venues, Carnegie Diner is known for its quick seating, late-night operating hours, and extensive menu ranging from breakfast-for-dinner options to craft cocktails and thick deli sandwiches.

Does Carnegie Diner offer gluten-free breakfast and lunch items?

Yes, several menu items accommodate gluten-free diets, including the Steak & Organic Eggs plate, BLT Quinoa Bowl, Chocolate Mousse, and the Impossible Vegan Burger served on a certified gluten-free bun.

Advertisement

Non-Affiliation & Fair Use Disclaimer

MenuRates is an independent restaurant menu archive and price directory. We are not officially affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to Carnegie Diner & Cafe or any of its subsidiaries. All registered trademarks, logos, brand names, and menu item names remain the sole property of their respective owners and are displayed here under Fair Use guidelines for informational purposes only. For menu corrections or takedown requests, please visit our Disclaimer or Contact Page.